UPSC Prelims 2017— Question 76

This question from the 2017 Civil Services Preliminary Examination tests Elections & Parliament, under Polity & Governance. The central concept is First-Past-the-Post and Presiding Officers. India generally uses the first-past-the-post system, so a candidate does not need 50% of votes to win. The Constitution also does not require that the Deputy Speaker must come from the Opposition, even though such a convention may operate politically. The safest way to approach this type of UPSC question is to identify the exact institutional, historical, geographical, scientific or economic proposition being tested and then examine every statement or option independently. A statement should not be accepted merely because it contains a familiar term; the qualifier, scope, date, institution and purpose must all be correct. This is particularly important where the answer choices combine several statements. Statement 1 is incorrect. It changes or overstates the relevant fact, institution, scope, chronology or mechanism, so it cannot be accepted as a correct proposition. Statement 2 is incorrect. It changes or overstates the relevant fact, institution, scope, chronology or mechanism, so it cannot be accepted as a correct proposition. Option-wise analysis: Option A: This is incorrect. It either accepts a statement that is not supported, rejects a statement that is correct, or identifies the wrong institutional, historical, geographical or scientific association. The error is therefore substantive rather than merely terminological. Option B: This is incorrect. It either accepts a statement that is not supported, rejects a statement that is correct, or identifies the wrong institutional, historical, geographical or scientific association. The error is therefore substantive rather than merely terminological. Option C: This is incorrect. It either accepts a statement that is not supported, rejects a statement that is correct, or identifies the wrong institutional, historical, geographical or scientific association. The error is therefore substantive rather than merely terminological. Option D: This is the correct answer. It matches the verified combination or proposition required by the question and is consistent with the underlying concept explained above. Prelims takeaway: Focus on the exact wording of the proposition, especially restrictive words such as “only”, “all”, “always”, “steadily”, “necessarily”, and references to a particular ministry, institution, law or geographical location. For statement-based questions, determine the truth value of each statement before looking at the combination codes. For direct questions, identify the defining feature of the concept and eliminate options that belong to a related but different concept. This method reduces dependence on guesswork and makes elimination more reliable.