UPSC CIVIL SERVICES PRELIMINARY EXAMINATION

UPSC Prelims 2019— Question 40

2019General Studies Paper-IPolity & GovernanceRights & Welfaremoderate
Q40

Question

Consider the following statements: As per the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Central (Amendment) Rules, 2018 1. if rules for fixed-term employment are implemented, it becomes easier for the firms/companies to lay off workers. 2. no notice of termination of employment shall be necessary in the case of temporary workman. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

Options

A
1 only
B
2 only
C
Both 1 and 2✓ Correct Answer
D
Neither 1 nor 2
AnswerOption C

Explanation

This question tests the concept of Fixed-Term Employment and Standing Orders. The key principle is that Fixed-term employment allows employers to engage workers for a defined period without treating the arrangement as permanent employment. The 2018 standing-order changes were intended to give legal recognition to fixed-term employment, and the relevant termination provisions distinguish temporary work from ordinary permanent employment. The correct answer marked for this question is option C. The distinction matters because UPSC often combines a familiar factual statement with one carefully qualified or overly broad statement. A reliable way to solve such questions is to identify the governing concept first and then test every statement against its precise wording rather than relying on general familiarity. The answer should therefore be selected only after checking whether each component of the option is consistent with the underlying constitutional, economic, scientific, historical or geographical principle. Option A — 1 only: This is not the correct choice. It either excludes a statement that must be included, includes a statement that is inaccurate, or identifies a different institution, process, location, technology or historical development from the one tested. Its wording should therefore be rejected when checked against the core principle described above. Option B — 2 only: This is not the correct choice. It either excludes a statement that must be included, includes a statement that is inaccurate, or identifies a different institution, process, location, technology or historical development from the one tested. Its wording should therefore be rejected when checked against the core principle described above. Option C — Both 1 and 2: This is the correct choice. It is consistent with the governing fact or with the valid combination identified above. The important point is not merely that the wording appears familiar, but that it matches the specific scope of the question and does not add an unsupported condition. Option D — Neither 1 nor 2: This is not the correct choice. It either excludes a statement that must be included, includes a statement that is inaccurate, or identifies a different institution, process, location, technology or historical development from the one tested. Its wording should therefore be rejected when checked against the core principle described above. In exam terms, the safest approach is to break the question into its smallest factual units. Where statements are combined, verify each statement independently and then compare the resulting combination with the four codes. Where the question asks for a single institution, event, technology or location, distinguish the exact term from closely related alternatives. This prevents elimination based only on familiarity and is especially useful in UPSC questions where one small qualifier can change the correctness of an otherwise plausible statement. Thus, after checking the individual propositions and the scope of the alternatives, option C is the answer.

Question Classification

SubjectPolity & Governance
TopicRights & Welfare
SubtopicTerminal topic
Question TypeStatement-based MCQ
Difficultymoderate
VerificationVerified